Descriptions of Clinical and Surgical Procedures
Snuffbox Radiocephalic Arteriovenous Fistula Creation for End-Stage Kidney Disease
Manuscript Format: Full Text
Transcription
CHAPTER 1
Hello, I'm Keith Ozaki, the John Manning Professor of Surgery here at Harvard Medical School, and I practice at Brigham and Women's Hospital. A practice that's now largely only dialysis access. Today, we're going to look at a snuffbox fistula creation, and snuffbox fistulas are actually about 30% of our practice here at the Brigham and Women's Hospital. It's something we've done recently over the last decade and grown the practice. 90% of the time, we're able to create an autogenous access for new access creations, and 90% of the time we're coming off the ulnar or radial. We're big fans of low and slow, just like southern barbecue. We want low flow initially to allow that vein to mature, but then we avoid the long-term complications such as aneurysmal degeneration from flow and balance, steal syndrome, cephalic arch burnout, arm edema, even cardiac complications over the long term. This snuffbox fistula also gives you a fallback in that if it doesn't work, at least you're maturing the artery and vein for the next step, Cimino. So we try to go as distally as possible. Today's case is a 38-year-old patient, and this kind of patient especially benefits in the overall life strategy of access creation in supporting this patient. He actually is left-handed, but we're going to go to the left side because the veins on the left were far superior than the veins on the right. For this case, we'll do a duplex to map out our plan A and our plan B. You'll see a pretty simple technical procedure, but a lot of it is dependent on the strategy that we develop with that duplex. For the snuffbox fistula, we tend to use a tourniquet to avoid the clamping of the arteries and associated vasospasm. You'll see us use a lot of a topical Normosol-papaverine solution to minimize vasospasm and endothelial injury. You'll see us use a side branch for the anastomosis. These arteries can be quite small. His is about two, two and a half millimeters, and you get a lot of spasm when you start touching them in these young patients. And then finally, at the end of the case, we want three things. We want evidence of high flow. We don't want any twists, kinks, or side branches that'll lead to early failure. And we want to make sure the hand's okay before we leave the operating room. I don't want to spoil the end of the movie here, but I will tell you that in the PACU, this patient has a nice audible holodiastolic bruit. So I think he's taking the first steps towards getting that catheter out. Thank you.
CHAPTER 2
Today we're doing an access creation in this patient with end-stage kidney disease. I like to do a preoperative duplex after induction of anesthetics. So we either do a regional and our team is very facile with regional anesthetics. Rarely we progress to general anesthesia for various reasons. And you always want to look at the arterial anatomy. Here you have a typical bifurcation of the brachial artery right near the antecubital crease. Sometimes you'll have a high takeoff of a radial that'll happen in about one out of 10 patients. The other thing I like to check is down at the wrist, he has a good radial pulse, but if you actually compress a little bit, you'll see that radial artery winking at you. It's a pretty large radial artery. Ulnar is actually a little smaller, so in some ways you might call him a little radial dominant. Now for the venous anatomy, we had the luxury of a venogram. And certainly someone with prior central catheters, a lot of IVs and stay in an ICU or where you don't see any good veins on duplex, we'll get a venogram. But here, one sees the formed cephalic vein that is nicely dilated. We had the room nice and warm. We aim to keep the patient very warm. And I'm going to go all the way out to the snuffbox here. The anatomic snuffbox is located right here on the hand and we see a vein, and I love to see this little bifurcation of the vein. You see the vein on top of the artery there. And that bifurcation can be used for an anastomosis. The radial artery is actually a reasonable caliber here. I'd say that this is a 2.5-millimeter artery and in our Journal of Vascular Surgery paper, that artery size is actually one of the biggest predictors as to whether you can get a fistula to work in the snuffbox. The other thing I like to check is the dimensions of the radial artery in the snuffbox. Occasionally there'll be a high branching of the radial artery here before the snuffbox, and one can see the forearm radial artery going out into the snuffbox. That artery is basically about that same 2- to 2.5-mm size. That planning allowed me to place an incision exactly where I want, especially with that bifurcation of the vein. I do have the fallback plan should the forearm cephalic not pan out that I could do something here in the antecubital. One can see that deep communicating vein going down. So right next to that proximal radial, that could be a plan B in the antecubital area. We don't typically give antibiotics in these clean cases that don't have any prosthetic material. We're trying to be good stewards of antibiotics, but I hear nearby hospitals that are even partners with us are pretty loosey goosey with antibiotics.
CHAPTER 3
So we have this patient shifted over to the ipsilateral side so we don't have to fight the bed whenever we create this access. Furthermore, I could put the pedestal down away from where we're going to be working. Here we're going to be so far distal that I'm going to use a glove to exclude the dirty fingernails. We're everting this glove over the hands. Occasionally you get lucky and all the fingers actually fit right into it. So we always prep out the entire arm to give us flexibility. And one of the advantages of the regional in addition to the vasodilation is it'll frequently give you time that if you're not happy with your plan A, you can then go to plan B and not worry about a patient that's getting uncomfortable with local or being at the top of the toxicity. For you, here's your Bovie. When you place the drapes here, I'm going to pull this out and let the Bovie hang. That'll give our anesthesiologist a little bit of space to deal with the airway. Will you hold the arm up for us please? One, two, three. Let's wrap that nice and smooth. Table up. So you'll notice throughout this case we use a solution that is pH-balanced. It's the Normosol solution, and we have four units of heparin per cc. We also have some papaverine to help out with vasospasm.
CHAPTER 4
Incision. You just get through the skin in one spot. You decide how you want to close it. Can you get to in one spot? Sorry? Get through the skin in one spot. He's a pretty young guy with thicker... Okay, one spot. That's pretty good, there. Adsons. Coag my right. Let's just get this little... Try not to pinch the skin. We avoid pinching the skin here, just the tip, just the tip. In these renal failure patients, one little wound dehiscence can be a big deal and often you can do it with little minimal trauma. You need a little bit more for the retractor. Okay, that's good.
CHAPTER 5
Hess, turkey foot, eyeball, tiny Tim, cross-action, Ohm Cricket. What do you like to call it? Cricket. Cricket. One of the names. Right now. So frequently we just kind of have a... Got like a small Senn? A quick look to identify where the vein is so we protect it. Pure cut there. Cutting would be fine. And before we dissect it out, you'll see I'll put a little of that Normosol on it to avoid the spasm. Of course, one of the challenges with snuffbox access creations can be the scale of the vessels for our typical loupes. Your choice cutting, coag. Vein solution. So you'll see the vein solution there. I'm going to kind of hydrodissect so that papaverine stays right in that soft tissue around the vein. Ragnell. I think I'll have a little better forehand going this way. Goldies, coag my right. Tenotomies. Do you have tenotomies? They're like that but smaller. Two, three Weitlaner. I entangled that. Tenotomies. And by lifting up, I'll create a little space for dissecting. In the teaching setting, I rarely operate alone, but here I can do forehand up a little bit and I'm just going to mobilize that vein enough. She'll do the outside. Goldies. Why don't you just, there's one little branch right here, cutting or coag, your choice. I'll need another Ray-Tec. And then why don't you dissect it out just a little bit and stay right on that vein. It's right on the anterior surface. Easy cut. Boom. Okay. Ray-Tec So you can see why I like to put a little donut, coag. We'll skip it. We'll skip it. So here I can get a sense of where that, there's one branch there. I think there's probably another one down the road, but we'll see if we could use these branches for the access creation. Pressure is 114. I can feel the artery. It's slightly towards Dr. Stetson's side. So I'm going to come over the top of that vein incise the fascia. Tenotomies. And there is a little nerve that runs through here, and you do want to be mindful to avoid damage to that nerve. Goldies. Goldies. Goldies. Goldies. No, no, no, no. Goldies, like these. Yeah. To get down to the fascia at the base of the snuffbox, a lot of times all you have to do is spread this, coag my left. And cutting on this one. Coag or cutting, your choice. Coag. Right angle. And this little bit of fascia, I would just use scissors, you know, just in case. If you lift that up and let's put that Bovie back in the hold or whatever. Just one cut, get through the fascia. Boom. Oh, you're still not through, I don't think. Grab it and lift up. I'll bluntly get through, I guess. Ragnell, and I'll hold this up now in case, if you do want a Bovie, but it's up to you. Often you'll get a sense of where a vein is. And that'll guide you where the artery is for these cases. We'll get a little bit more length. I would use Bovie. See that little branch in there? Cutting even is fine, but I'm on that skin. And then if you hold that up in the air. Vein solution. Again, I'm going to place a little papaverine into the soft tissues. Tenotomies. To help with the vasospasm. He's pretty young chronologically and doesn't have a lot of athero and calcifications that'll keep him from spasming. We find these lower-flow fistulas are especially beneficial in young patients since over time the high-flow fistulas will have certainly a risk of steal, arm edema, you can burn out the cephalic arch, but recent, hold that straight up, work by my partner, Dr. Hussain, coag my left, shows that even these patients don't do well and they get more cardiac complications when they have high-flow fistulas. He also showed that when you do a Cimino, there tends to be fewer 30-day thrombotic events without much bleeding, Tenotomies, when you give heparin. So we tend to give heparin for these cases. One of the nice things about using a tourniquet is I won't have to circumferentially dissect out that artery. Ragnell. Hold that straight up. I think you can do that pretty well. Tenotomies. Should be good, I think.
CHAPTER 6
Okay. Heparin or not? Do you want to give heparin or not? Yeah. Okay. How much? 2000. Heparin, 2,000, IV, now, Dr. Stetson wants. And then how do you want to close the skin? How do you want to do the anastomosis? Just do staples for closing the skin. 2000 of heparin is in. Thank you. Ragnell. I think you can get a little bit more maybe. What needle, what suture do you want to do the anastomosis? 6-0, BV1. So more that way? I think I better get a little bit. Tenotomies.
CHAPTER 7
So now that we've given the heparin, we'll go back and harvest the vein. Can you hold that up in the air? Tenotomies. If you hold up, it'll help me. Just set that side. Often there are little branches in the crotch of this bifurcation. Right angle. 3-0 silk tie. Let's tie this. You can let go of your left. I think you can take that Ragnell out. 3-0 silk tie. So you just tie this one. Occasionally for the snuffbox, the trainee will choose a 7-0. She's chosen a 6-0 on a BV1 needle, way towards you. Metz. And she's given heparin, so now we have a little stasis and endothelial injury in this, but the heparin will systemically protect. We of course need to give that heparin before we put up the tourniquet. Tenotomies. Right angle. Tenotomies. A lot of times you're lucky and valves will keep this from bleeding too much. And then I think you can tie that and I'll just hold this and you get that 3-0. Metz. Make sure it's a good throw on that. I didn't... Okay. So I think you can leave that for now. You want a Jake?
CHAPTER 8
Why don't you inject a little vein solution? We'll take the arterial cannula if you have it, the plastic one there. Why don't you inject a little vein solution here? We're going to give a little systemic papaverine. So she's going to forehand inject this. You'll probably need a forceps in your hand to hold that. I'll get a Jake. The Jake to me. One, two, three, place it. You need to grab the vein wall and shove it in. Yep. And I'll gently hydrodistend that, but we got to be careful we don't overpressurize it. That's good. So that heparin and papaverine with that pH balance solution now, that's good, will sit on that while we're getting this arm exsanguinated. You want to wrap or hold? I can wrap. Okay.
CHAPTER 9
So I'm going to elevate this arm a lot, squeeze the hand, go ahead. And she's going to pull pretty taut because he's got a big muscular arm. And we'll typically inflate this to 225 or 250. Very useful, I think, for access operation. Go, go, go, go, go. Wrap, wrap, wrap, wrap. Keep wrapping. Keep wrapping. Mostly gets the venous blood out. Inflate tourniquet, keep wrapping. Okay, off. Many of our vascular surgeons get neck issues. You'll notice that I have a step between my legs. Then I can step up and down without having to bend over. And I have about a four-inch range. Edna. The pillow I put underneath this arm board allows me to just kind of grab into that pillow. Furthermore, the arm boards, if I raise and lower the table, the post isn't in the way. Two, three, Weitlaner. Goldies.
CHAPTER 10
Dietrich scissors, they’re like small pots. So I'm going to try to take this cut in the vein right out that little side branch. Geralds. So now we can have a nice big hood. One more time. I want you to lay a little papaverine-Normosol-heparin solution in there. Uh-huh. Just blow out. Okay. That's good.
CHAPTER 11
What do you think? Right there? Yep. All right. Open wet lap ready. So you go ahead and get your 11 blade. 11 blade to her. Super flat. Come in super flat. Just the anterior wall. Three quarters of the way in and cut up. Cut up. It's very easy to back wall this. Dietrich scissors. Dietrichs. They're like small pots. Oh, these. Vein solution. We'll take the arterial cannula on the vein solution. Blot it once. I'm just flushing out a little blood. Then we'll dry up that field. Goldies, then you'll feel comfortable sewing. Geralds. Go ahead. You'll get to that in a second. Yeah. Geralds, and then the 6-0 suture.
CHAPTER 12
I tend to run just one Prolene around unless I've got a situation where I need a toe stitch, small bite, yep, take it. It's simpler in a teaching setting and I think the... Shot? No, you're just going to do inside out on the heel. Remember? Huh? No, you went outside in. So now you're going to inside out with the same needle. That'll avoid you having to change needles. Inside out on the heel, not the toe, the heel. Yep. And then do you just do one interrupted, or parachute down? No, well, you'll see. She's just going to tie this down, and the visualization will be pretty good. Take it. Selectively, I'll parachute, but... You want to just grab that needle. Get these on the same side. So take your needle. So do you want it on this side? Is that what you're saying? Yeah. Okay. Pull it up. She's going to tie this about half and half. And typically we do the side first that the vein is coming from. Here it's coming a little bit from my side, so I think we should do my side. A purist will say you should do the toe forehand towards yourself so we would finish on this side, but I let the trainee choose right angle. There's stuff on that. Nope, nope, nope, nope. Let go. Yep. So that is now going over to your side because you wanted to tie on that. Needle driver. And you want this suture on a little bit of tension. So she'll hang it where it's hanging by gravity right there. Geralds So that's not on any tension.Yep. And here I just will take the smallest bite in the world to get it to the inside. Then I think if you follow this up in the air. I always think of how much pressure's going to be in an anastomosis with access. Certainly if it's a tube, flow will be the same throughout the tube, but the pressure could be quite different at different ends of the tube. So if you follow with your right, hold over the heel with your left, then I'll be able to rapidly do this in one. Relax. Let me just look at it. I think if you hold over there, I'm not sure. Relax your right hand. There's a little fold that's up in there. Okay. Now you grab over that heel right there where that needle is. See the heel right here where the needle is. So come outside in, inside out. You would lift that up classically to show it to me. Let go. Lift that up? Oh, you would flip the suture over to... So pull the heel over towards you like that. And then that'll show me this. And of course, the biggest stitches will be there in the middle. Let go. Shod to me. Now you can do a few on your side. Certainly this stitch he's about to do is a key one. Outside in, a small bite. Really don't even have to do much with that left. Small but just mean near the edge. Yep. Okay. Just let go. So just let go of it. So now you can get it in a lot. Go ahead. Small near the edge. Take it. Take it. Just let go. Pronate, then supinate. Maybe you'll be able to get them in one. Notice we don't have a suction. Often I find trainees will just tend to want to hold a suction. It damages the inside of blood vessels. So usually you can just blot with a Ray-Tec for these, just right straight across. Yeah. And do it. Don't advance too much, advance it too much. Go towards your last one. Take it out. Yep. Take it. Boom. Yep. So let go. So watch what I do. I pull that back and that pops that needle up a little way. Furthermore, it gets the suture out of the way. These are nice training cases because a trainee can do an anastomosis yet not have to harvest vein all day. Remember these in the middle should be your larger ones. That is farther from the edge. I'm going to pull that, try to give you a little more room. One more, then I have the toe forehand towards myself. See it? Take it. Don't load it. Don't load it? Nope. You hold that up. Dietrich scissors. I'm going to trim this. We could of course make the anastomosis a little longer. Nope, don't shod it. Needle driver. So you'll follow your right. Maybe hold it over the heel of your left at some point will be of value, especially as I round the corner. Right there. Let go. And now you'll find if you hold over that heel back here, you'll open it up for me. You can let go. I'm going to show this one more time, kind of rolling it like that. You got to pull up with your right. Maybe I'll have to do this in two. We'll see. I think I'm comfortable that back wall is off of there. Let go. So you hold over the heel, try to make that end opened up. We have a little more ooze than usual, but I don't mind a little blood on there to keep those endothelial cells, now you flip that back, a little moist. You may have a little scallop or two to repair, but we'll see. So let me just show you. Let go. Maybe like way back there. I'm going to try to use up a little of that extra vein there. Follow up. Put this back on tension. Let go. Pull up, pull up towards you, yeah. Let go. One more. Get ready to cut a needle for us, please. Oh see, we may have to put a little... Cut the needle. No, other side. The other side? Yeah, that way you won't lose it. If you just cut it, I'll pass it on this driver, but... Needle back. Got it. You want wet hand or not? No squirt. So we'll let the tourniquet down. If there's hemorrhage, we can blow it right back up. Tourniquet down. Tourniquet going down. Goldies. Tourniquet down. Thank you. Metz. And then now you just pull this this way.
CHAPTER 13
Certainly if we pressurize it, we'll test it for bleeding. Just want to have a quick look to make sure it's patent. Two, three, save the long or the 6-0. There's a little something over in the heel. Maybe a little something right there. When you're feeling... I always think of three things at the end of an access case that you want to make sure are okay before you leave the OR. Is there evidence of high flow? Are there twists, kinks, or side branches that'll lead to early failure? And then finally, is the hand okay? I don't worry that much about the snuffbox here in the hand, but certainly with a tourniquet, I at least want to make sure there's an ulnar pulse over there, that I didn't crack a plaque up in the upper arm, et cetera. The side branches, we won't go after the ones in this upper part of the arm. And already I'm starting to feel evidence of high flow. Tourniquet up. I'm going to have one little look here. Tourniquet going up. To make sure we get this completely dry. There's a little folded something. Ragnell. I tend to leave... Ragnell, it's like a small Senn. I tend to leave this sort of adventitial connection here till the end and only take what I want because sometimes it'll be your friend. Keep you from twisting. I think you can take a little of this. She's watching for side branches. Why don't I just take that right on up there just a little bit more. A little bit here. Okay, so let's look closely at this now. There's a little arterial branch there. I don't... I think that fold, 6-0, will end it. Okay. You want to tie that down? I think it'll quell that. Metz. Tourniquet down. - [Doctor] Tourniquet going down. Should be fine. Shod that. Two, three Weitlaner. We'll take a doppler on the field. Certainly you see this augmen- augmentation means when you occlude the outflow, see how that basically becomes an artery? And with a pressure of 100 right now, we may have a little hard time feeling a thrill through his relatively long arm. Often you don't really feel it here much until the vasospasm has relaxed. Vein solution. Fresh Ray-Tec. Oh, vein solution. And I'm just going to let this vein solution sit there. We're going to put staples in the skin. It's the trainee's choice. Sometimes patients with renal failure have such thin skin, it's hard to do a subcuticular. The staples also kind of mark to a dialysis unit where he recently had surgery, but also it can be an anchor to draw people back to clinic. This is a very dependable patient, but if you ever worry about people coming back for follow up, that's a nice way to make sure they come. We'll tend to see him at two or three weeks and then we'll...
CHAPTER 14
And I'm kind of just doing this mostly for demonstration purposes. Two, three Weitlaner. No jelly. So... So you want that holodiastolic signal. Now will you occlude the outflow intermittently? It goes away. I'm going to now do this. Kind of the first branches are pretty soon, but I'm not going to go... If I can get them through the same incision, I will. Here's the distal radial. Not much steal. But the key is it's not the volume that you hear. You want to hear hollow diastolic. You want to hear this throughout diastole. And that's clearly evidence of high flow right there. Doppler off.
CHAPTER 15
And so we'll now just make sure this is dry, put in a couple of staples. For access cases with that low-pressure conduit in there. I tend not to put deep stitches if there's not too much dead space. And then certainly elevating the arm post-op, we don't want to grab it here because we'll pressurize the anastomosis. We'll grab it at the fingers. At about six weeks is where we make a judgment as whether we're going to need adjunctive procedures like side branch ligations, fasciotomies, lipectomies, or other revisions or imaging. And the, four out of five people in our practice that get something like a snuffbox will need a second procedure to get it to a usable state. But again, this could be one that could last a long time for him. Questions? Things I've missed? Questions? For all throughout the arteries, your dose of heparin... I thought you said 2,000? Yes, he said 2,000. You know, we - there's gonna be like 30 minutes we'll really need the heparin. And some people don't give heparin for these. If I go through these in other countries, heparin's not always available. We often don't have an IV even. So we just go with pace in that setting. But I do think, based on the evidence from Dr. Hussain, there is a benefit with very little risk for... And again, I don't give a whole lot because these people already have platelet dysfunction and they also have venous hypertension from us connecting a vein to an artery. So there's a lot of reasons they'll get oozy, but with elevation, a little bit of time, we tend not to need topical thrombostatic agents, et cetera. I don't bring any topical thrombostatic agents onto the field. The last thing I want is thrombin that gets on a little pair of forceps that's suddenly in the lumen. I think the components of your vein solution, you said Normosol and then how much of the heparin and papaverine? The heparin I know is four units per cc. I believe that... Chrissy, can you read off the bag for the Normosol vein solution? I believe it's either 30 or 60 of papaverine and... 60 of papaverine. In 500? Yeah. 60 of papaverine and 500. 60 milligrams of papaverine. Always let your anesthesiologist know if you're going to inject it IV. A couple of times I've seen people drop their pressure and they can't understand why. I think that's a pretty beautiful case. All right. Thank you. Let's just look around now. Two, three. Goldies. Let's just make sure we're dry. Vein solution. You okay with it? There's something that's now under your Weity. Say it again. There's something that is now under your Weity. Oh, that's oozing? Yeah, just this. It's okay now. Ragnell. A lot of vasospasm. Cutting on the right. Anything else? Geralds. Okay. Sloppy wet.
CHAPTER 16
Dry. Toothed Adsons. We'll close this in a way that if there is blood that develops under pressure, then it'll come out between the staples. That's the other advantage of this over the subcuticular. If you pull too much skin, you can actually lose the flow because it extrinsically compresses it. Jelly. We'll take a Band-Aid. We'll use these Band-Aids. They're cheap. Doppler on. They can be changed in the PACU, et cetera, and it's pretty gentle on the skin of patients. Will you occlude the outflow? Come off. Okay, come on. Okay. So that's direct evidence. Come off. That we have high flow. Okay. And we make sure that's dry. Go ahead. If you put on your Band-Aid just right gently across, not pressing down hard. If we're worried about a patient, we'll give them even a little sub-Q heparin in the PACU. Table to the ground, spot's off, reverse-T, a little antithrombotic adjunct, obviously not evidence-based. And early, again, I'm just going to elevate this. Hypertension, of course, will help flow through this. One of the nice things about the arm boards is you can angle it. And we'll listen with a regular stethoscope just to see if we can hear any bruit. And that gives a hard endpoint for nursing to follow post-op. We can give that stethoscope to the patient and let them be a partner in their care.
CHAPTER 17
This patient, you'll see, will have a couple of staples for his wound closure. This allows fluids to leak out through the incision if necessary. He'll come back in a couple of weeks to have those staples out. We'll ensure that the access is maturing. We'll teach him a little bit about hand exercising and protecting the veins, certainly in that arm. Then at about six weeks, we'll see him and decide, do we need any imaging? Do we need adjunctive procedure such as side branch ligations, lipectomies, fasciotomies, or is this access one that is perhaps ready to use in the coming weeks after that six-week visit? And we reinforce to patients that access creation is not a one and done. It's a lifelong commitment to a program. And when we create a fistula, we tell people we have about a four out of five chance in our hands that we can get something to work, but it also will take four to six months and four out of five people will need a secondary procedure to get that access ready to use. I think that relationship is very important with a patient, teaching them about their access, it is their lifeline, making sure there's good communication with the centers. And we work very closely with interventional nephrology in our hospital for the complementary approaches of open and endovascular. I think access creation requires the ability to be nimble in your decision makings. You know, by a lot of series, half of these don't work well, and we've probably gotten it up to about two out of three, but you know, very few things in vascular surgery have such high failure rates. There are emerging adjuncts in the pipeline that I think will supplement our clinical practice, but a lot of it is, I think, planning well, recognizing when there's a problem, and being willing to jump to the next step for the care of the patient. I think this is a great one for a team sport approach in that if my patient doesn't do well and someone else needs to go in and do a thrombectomy or revision, the patient recognizes our practice as a team that will take care of them, open experts, endovascular experts, et cetera. Thanks very much. It's been an honor to teach you. I really like to make sure that the next generations of surgeons knows how to do this well so you can do my access creation in the next decade. Thank you.




