Sign Up

Ukraine Emergency Access and Support: Click Here to See How You Can Help.

Video preload image for Arthroscopic Total Shoulder Resurfacing with Osteochondral Allograft
jkl keys enabled
Keyboard Shortcuts:
J - Slow down playback
K - Pause
L - Accelerate playback
  • Introduction
  • 1. Diagnostic Arthroscopy
  • 2. Transhumeral Sleeve Placement
  • 3. Prepare the Humeral Head
  • 4. Prepare the Glenoid Surface
  • 5. Prepare the Allografts
  • 6. Place the Glenoid Graft
  • 7. Place the Humeral Graft
  • Discussion

Arthroscopic Total Shoulder Resurfacing with Osteochondral Allograft


Ruben Gobezie, MD; Samuel Dubrow, MD
University Hospitals of Cleveland, Case Medical Center



So my name is Reuben Gobezie. I'm the chief of the shoulder and elbow service at University Hospitals of Cleveland, Case Medical Center. And what we're going to do today is we’re going to review a new or relatively new procedure called arthroscopic biological total shoulder resurfacing. So this is an arthroscopic surgery, and essentially what we do in order to achieve a cartilage transplant in the shoulder using this technique is - we bring the patient in. You'll see when we first put the scope in the shoulder, I'll do a routine diagnostic arthroscopy, look at everything, make sure the rotator cuff is intact, make sure that - that the chondral loss is what I thought it was going to be before the surgery, and then size up the humeral head and the glenoid graft sizes cuz there are different sizes I can transplant. Next we're gonna - you're going to see that we take out the rotator interval and remove the biceps from the field - gives us more working room - and then we'll start with the procedure where we start to reprepare the surfaces of the humeral head and the glenoid so that they can receive the graft.

This is a - a patient that essentially has classic osteoarthritis of the shoulder, albeit at a young age, and the options for him today in my practice would be a total shoulder placement with conventional prostheses or one of these alternative graft procedures not osteochondral graft, which I think don’t - have - have fallen out of favor - I don’t use it anymore - or this osteochondral grafting. I think - debridement has already been tried; it did not work for him and so here’s where we’re at - basically a bipolar graft.


Okay good. So here we have the glenohumeral joint, and you see here is that there is a - some grade one and two and three changes. Then you get down to here, and you see there's a grade four change. See what I mean? There’s a grade 4 change. Likewise on the humerus, it’s completely denuded of cartilage. It’s a grade 4. So you get way up here, and you can see that there is some cartilage there. The rotator interval is here. The subscap is there. And then the vy - the rotator cuff superiorly is still intact, right there. And then he has, of course, a normal degenerative superior fraying, te - tenotomized the biceps already. And now what we’re going to do is we’re going to go into the rest of the surgery here.


We’re going to resect the rotator interval now. And essentially that’s what we’re going to do now; we’re going to resect the rotator interval. These are very, you know, every - each - each of these arthroscopic totals are done in a very different character and - and based on the soft tissue tightness of the shoulder and so on. So here I’m going all the way out with the rotator interval resection. You have to go all the way out past - just the capsule that’s deep - and all the way out until you see deltoid fibers because, when you’re passing instrumentation, you really want to be careful to make sure that you get that so you can pass instruments easily, you see? And then you can see here, the conjoined tendon is coming up in the left side of your screen there, here. And then what we're going to do is widen the skin incision, and then we’re going to put a drill guide here, which is 25 mm in diameter. And visualization is key because you have such m - so much outflow. I'm introducing now the - the guide, and you see here that I keep this guide - you have to be very careful of the axillary nerve here, and I keep this guide here in a position where I feel like I can assess the humeral head. And there you go.

Okay I think that's a good position for it. I'm going to go below the center cuz, remember, it’s only a 35 mm guide. I’m going to go below the center here where... Okay good - and hold that, Sam, for me. Now I'm going to come out, and I’m going to take this and I'm going to do this, here. Okay, knife. Eleven-blade, Gaby. Eleven-blade. Okay, good. And that tells me where it is in the skin. It’s kind of the angle. Show me the - show me it sitting on the b - bone. There you go, good. And then I’m going to make an incision here. Okay and then what I’m going to do next is I’m going to spread with the - a schnidt because the axillary nerve is here, and I can tell you, I had a scare recently where I had a - a - not a palsy - yeah, I had a transient palsy. Let me tell you something, it’s a - a game changer - makes this procedure not worth it if you can’t obviously get - if you get a nerve palsy.

Okay good, and then so now what I’m going to do is I'm going to slide this little groove in there and then - feed that for me, feed that - there you go. See the pin’s there. So remove this - take a mallet - and then what you do - and then a grasper for the pin, and what I do is knock it in so my assistant can hold it. So here we go. So, you just grab this here. And okay, so this one still has a loop on it. It’s the old one, but it should be fine. Okay. So then you grab it like that. So now we want a dilator, tissue protector there and next. Okay good. Alright, so here’ a 55 - 5.5 millimeter reamer and... oh. Take off the tissue protector and you go to the 5-5 reamer, and then basically it’s going to go through the outer cortex of the humerus.

Okay. Okay guys. I’m going to take this out. This needs to come off first. Okay good. Alright, good. So now we’re going to go in and put the transhumeral sleeve there. Good, now you can let go. Now we can take it off. Okay good. So now what you have here is a… the transhumeral sleeve, and you see here - can you stop the outflow? You see here that that’s really in the center of the head.


Now what we’re going to do is go progressively to the reamers. So - yes, thanks. You’re going to take a 20 millimeter reamer, okay and you’re going to introduce that into the shoulder joint first. Just introduce that right into the shoulder joint through the rotator interval that you see there. And then what we’ll do is - sometimes I put a little bit of pressure on the arm to get it open like that. And then I’ll take the stick, the transhumeral sleeve, guide, and pin, and I’ll put that in there like that. And now I just need to see where is that central bit there, and it’s right down there. Just kind of have to work it in there. And once you get that in there, boom! Just lock it in there like that. Usually, it goes in without too much difficulty. And you see that that’s locked in there. And then you’re ready to retrograde ream.

So now, we’re going to take the drill - okay, good. And then what we’re going to do is pull back on the sleeve here. It locks on, and then we’re ready to go. And hopefully it doesn’t take us too long. I’ll pull back on the - on the transhumeral sleeve here - try to get some better tissue. And you just gotta apply gentle traction and be very patient.

So now what I’ll do is I’ll go into the anterior portal here. Back up. T handle on this thing for me. T handle. And then I’ll put the T handle on here. Yep. And I’ll back this - just unwind this thing here. It’s kind of cool because you’re putting the instruments together in vivo - you know, inside the shoulder joint. And what you see here - then yea, exactly. See I’m showing you? What you see here now is a nicely appointed humeral head resurfacing. I don’t think we’re going to have to go much bigger than that on the joint - on the humer. I think it looks pretty good. Now the glenoid - because that’s really where the action is on this guy’s shoulder.


Okay so now, again, I’m going to center this where I think the biggest part of the pathology is, and I just position the arm in a way that I feel like it will help me achieve that goal. So you see here that the arthritis is down there, and you kind of want this glenoid resurfacing to be where the arthritis is. So now the question is getting the arm in the right position for the transhumeral sleeve. Is always fun. To me - okay, good. Okay. Okay good. And then turn your eyes the other way so I can see the glenoid and make sure that I’m in the right spot with the glenoid. Make that - we’re just going to bury this to the harvest and back out. Okay. And then what we’ll do is take this down here. You can sort of back this out a little bit. Show me what’s going on here please. Back this out a little bit here, so you can disconnect those two. And then you can pull this out. Okay cool. So then, again, I’m going to introduce those anagrade reamer now, and that’s going to beone where I kinda have to see where I'm coming in from. The anagrade reamer - looks like I lost it. Somehow I need to…

Let' see here. Alright, so now - now what I’m going to do is find out where’s that nipple. Keep your hand there just cuz I - I need to just kind of think - okay, good. I’m going to try and find that nipple here. Okay, so that nipple needs to be buried in there. What I’m going to do to do that is, sometimes I move the arm in the armpit, a little bit out. You know what I mean? there you go. It seems to fit right in there. So, you see what I’m doing? So this is technically a demanding operation for this reason. Really, it requires every skill you have in arthroscopy: anterior portal visualization, posterior portal visualization, orientation - I mean literally - it’s like everything. So, you know. Okay so now we’ve got to get this thing back into this hole. Once you get in there, it’s kind of refreshing and nice and all that good stuff. Okay and then use that to manipulate it, and there you go. Once you get in - okay, right there - that’s it. Okay good. Okay is this a drill?

Okay so now I’ll basically - I’ll basically just ream it. And this is the hardest - usually, the hardest part of the reaming job. Yeah, okay good - we’re getting what we want out of this thing, you see that? Just - you just have to double check and make sure that you’re getting what you need out of this thing. And sometimes, what I’ll do is I’ll move it to the anterior portal for this portion, and for whatever reason, it seems that this is a good position to see my - yeah, can you hold that? Thank you. Forgot about that. It’s a good portion - position to see my reaming. Yeah it is, right there - okay good. So there’s - there’s the view I’m looking for there. Put that in. Okay good. Give me that view there. And so, now what I do usually is I - I stick this - no - this way. Got to - I start to - to move the shoulder so that I can close the goal - hole, if you will. Yea, that gap right there. I think we got a good rim there, good rim there, good rim there, good rim there. I think it looks good.

Okay, so now what we’re going to do is prep the humeral head cuz that’s done already on that side too. Alright, and then… Yeah.


What we really want to do is the K wires. View your side - your side. You can put it back in that holster. Hammer or drill? Huh, that's kind of misleading, huh? Why is that moving? It’s pretty cool, isn’t it? Okay, so now what we get to do is saw the top off. So what we really need are some good holdings on this thing. Yeah, I’m going to need you to do it in a way that you - I can still get in there. Yeah. Don't let that thing come out - come out of there. Okay. So there it is, there. By 5 millimeters, right? Five millimeters good?

Here’s a tibial - here’s a distal tibia. This is an ankle joint. And then we’re going to put this similarly. Okay good. So now we take that out like this. You want to hold? So once again we got a nice little graft - but you see how it’s U-ed there? It’s never going to be flat when you put it in a scope. So just remember that it doesn’t matter. Twenty - that’s fine. Twenty millimeter by five millimeter depth. And so this one… Here it is - a 20-by-5 millimeter and that - that’s quite thin, which is typical of a distal tibia. Okay, let’s have the - let’s have the pulsed lavage. Let’s have a fresh bowl and a pulsed lavage. Alright - just to clean off the person’s - you know - own blood. Okay. Cool. Okay. And a knife back to you. Now we’re going to do this, and we’re going to - this is from the blood - patient’s own blood. It’s called ACP, you know what I mean? And basically, it’s - it’s a platelet-rich plasma der - basically derivative version of that. Okay, so let’s get back into the shoulders, let’s get back to the real part of the surgery here.


Grafting place is right here. There’s the graft side. And it’s sort of finicky, but it’s pretty cool. Okay so now, what we’re going to do is we’re going to insert the graft. Very important step here: not to lose the cannulation. I think that’s where I got that exterior nerve last time. So don’t let me pull that out, okay? Here, hold it up here. Hold it up there. Hold that. Hold that. Don’t let go right now. I need - I need you to help me because I can’t - this is where it gets kind of tricky. Pretty much in the site isn’t it? Okay. Isn’t it pretty much in site? Looks like to me too. Yeah it’s in there. It’s in the site there, so - see there? Good. Almost seems like a…

Okay, implant. Plunger. Shoot. That drill - that - that - that bone is really good. Okay, so that’s okay. What we’ll do is we’ll come back and get that guy in a second. Okay so now let’s go and do round two. Okay good, drill. Help me. Kind of go in-and-out to really get that thing in there. That went in a lot there. You should grab - you saw that disc? Guess we just get rid of this. There you go.


Grasper. Okay. Okay let go. Just come in with this grasper here. Okay, good. Good. Good. Okay. Good. Right in his right. Ohhhhhh. Ahhhhhhh. Really good. Okay good. No, no just ta - Okay guys, thanks everybody.

I think it’s a well recognized need in our field - that is to say, trying to address successfully the arthritis in a young patient. And we know from the literature, the group - work done out of Mayo Clinic and others - where essentially, young patients, who have a shoulder arthroplasty, they don’t last as long, and their satisfaction is less. And trying to address that issue. And there have been many different ways people have done it through biologically grafting, using Achilles tendons, dermal matrices, and so on. Not satisfactory results, so the natural next, in my mind, move was to go where the knee had gone several decades ago and - and - and really try to develop this area of cartilage transplant for the shoulder. And it's nice because osteochondral graft is really the only way, to this day, that we have of making a graft or chondral procedure that is biomimetic - that actually reproduces the mature, hyaline cadage - cartilage that you’d see in a - in a normal joint. The rest of them really don’t reproduce that. You know, the - the microfractures, the autologous chondrocyte implantations - they don’t - they don’t achieve that whereas the chondrocyte or the osteochondral graft transplant does.

And so, you know, there are some technical challenges. You asked me about another challenge we have with this procedure, is we’re trying to build this in and trying to really figure it out. Is - is the issue of - of what you do with a deformed humerus and glenoid. And in those cases, doing it arthroscopically may not be the optimal way because you just can’t reach where you need to go to correct the deformity, and so I’ve started to move now into open procedures with larger grafts and so on. So, there are some things we need to work out. The other thing is we don’t know how long these last, and I think that’s another really big point. But if it reflects what’s been seen in the knee with reasonable 10 and 15 year survivorship, then, you know, I think we’ve done these younger patients a real service.

Why is this procedure new? It’s new because - it’s new and old. I mean I’ll tell you, it’s built upon decades of research in the knee literature where fresh osteochondral grafting, which is what this procedure is about, taking a fresh osteochondral graft, and transplanting it into the shoulder, has been done in the knee since the 1970s. And there’s a lot of data on that and a lot of research that has gone into that. What we’re really doing is trying to take the patient who is younger, you know, typically below 50 years of age - oftentimes in 20s and 30s - that has significant osteoarthritis or a chondral loss, whether focal or global, and we’re trying to transplant the cartilage that they’ve lost in the shoulder joint. And that concept is - is somewhat new in the sense that arthroscopically, we’ve - I’ve developed a technique to do it arthroscopically and, on top of that, as a bipolar graft - both of the socket and the humerus. So in this case, it’s - it’s novel in that technique. Other guys have done this procedure, such as JP Warner and Brian Cole, as a unipolar graft, meaning only the humeral head, as an open procedure, and I’m just building on their work.

Well the benefit of a surgery like this is, in theory, to have an outpatient rotator cuff sparing procedure that eliminates the need, we hope, at least for a time, for metal and plastic prostheses, such as a total shoulder replacement or partial shoulder replacement, and transplant with biological living tissue, such as cartilage, which is what usually the issue is in that patient’s shoulder - they’ve lost cartilage.

I can tell you I’ve been doing this for almost two years now. And there are a couple of hurdles, and it’s a learning curve - somebody’s got to do it in order for us to develop the - the, you know, the solution, so to speak. But you know, one of the hurdles that I’ve learned the hard way is - that is - the question - answering the question of what size graft is enough graft to cover the ball and socket joint adequately to address the symptomatology. And what I found in the early work so far is is that while the grafts really don’t fail - I’ve not had a problem with graft failure when we follow up with MRI scan. What I have seen in some patients is, the larger bone patients, the 30 millimeter grafts that we were initially doing and still do, are just simply just not enough graft. I’ve had the opportunity to scope the shoulder after that and have seen that there’s, you know, just not enough coverage. And so the question is what is the right size? And that’s something that’s going to be worked out over the next decade, I’m sure. But, you know, we’ve moved into this direction, and I think this is a very important move for the field.

Share this Article


Filmed At:

University Hospitals of Cleveland, Case Medical Center

Article Information

Publication Date
Article ID1
Production ID0001